_edited.png)
Think about what real impact means. It isn’t measured by hitting numbers on a spreadsheet.
Real impact is alive; it breathes. It roots itself in the community, changes the soil, and leaves something lasting. It’s quiet sometimes, subtle.
And often, it’s everything that a number can’t touch.
When we let funder-defined metrics dictate our path, we’re not dancing to our own rhythm. We’re out of sync with what our communities need. We end up chasing someone else’s version of “success,” but that’s commerce, not development. That’s why real impact—measured by what transforms lives—won’t be found in a target or a tidy metric. It’s found in lives uplifted, growth you can’t quantify, change that doesn’t fit in a box.
For South African NGOs, shifting from this numbers game to something deeper, more substantial, means embracing a new approach.
By aligning our work with the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), National Development Plan (NDP), municipal Integrated Development Plans (IDPs), and filtering it through Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) frameworks, we’re grounding ourselves in standards that speak to more than just funder expectations.
These metrics aren’t perfect, but they’re established by independent entities and, in their purest form, reflect the data we have and the voices of our communities. With this foundation, we’re free to focus on impact as it’s truly felt.
South African NGOs often find themselves working to meet targets set by funders, playing to someone else’s metrics.
Goodhart’s Law puts it bluntly: “When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.”
The more we lean into funder-defined success, the less it reflects real progress. And if we’re not careful, that commerce-driven approach could reshape development itself, moving it away from purpose and into metrics that don’t actually mean anything on the ground.
To create change that lasts, we need a shift. At GrowZA, we’ve chosen a model that aligns with SDGs, the NDP, IDPs, and ESG frameworks. These standards, while not flawless, bring the wisdom of independent, established entities into the equation.
They’re grounded in accessible data and are designed, at least in theory, to reflect community priorities rather than funder whims. With this alignment, our work is not only pragmatic but sustainable and genuine. Here’s why that approach works and how it creates real, measurable impact.
Why Funder-Driven Metrics Often Miss the Mark
Funders tend to love numbers that can tell a “quick success” story—attendance counts, units distributed, sessions held. But in reality, development is never quick, and impact isn’t always tidy. Funder-driven metrics risk overshadowing the deeper, more complex work that truly changes lives.
Here’s how:
Shallow Measures for Deep Work
High attendance or a big distribution number doesn’t guarantee meaningful change. True impact often grows slowly, through resilience and consistency. Quick wins may look good on paper but miss the depth of real transformation.
Mission Drift
When funders drive the mission, NGOs start drifting from their true purpose. The focus shifts to what funders want, sometimes at the cost of core values. A mission-first approach can’t be built on a foundation of short-term metrics.
Administrative Burden Over Program Work
Especially for smaller NGOs, the pressure to report in ways that satisfy funders can pull resources away from the field and into reporting requirements. Every hour spent on paperwork is an hour not spent with the community.
Gaming the System
The need to secure funding can lead to reporting “wins” that don’t truly reflect what’s happening on the ground. In the long term, this can undermine trust, authenticity, and the integrity of the nonprofit sector.
GrowZA’s Impact Model: A Balanced, SDG-Led Approach
At GrowZA, we believe that aligning with SDGs, NDP, IDPs, and ESG frameworks isn’t just a compliance exercise. It’s a way to root ourselves in standards that reflect genuine, community-centered priorities. These frameworks aren’t perfect metrics, but they have a unique advantage: they’re not shaped by funders. They’re established by independent organizations and, in their truest form, reflect the voices and needs of the communities we work with.
This model allows us to:
Set relevant goals with universal and local appeal. Goals like education, poverty reduction, and gender equality are both globally recognized and grounded in what communities truly value.
Stay focused on local impact first. By linking our work to municipal IDPs and the NDP, we ensure that our metrics reflect South African needs and long-term national goals.
Translate impact for a funder audience through ESG. By expressing our work through an ESG lens, we connect local efforts to a broader global narrative, aligning with funder expectations while staying true to community needs.
This framework enables us to communicate impact on our terms, aligning with a broader audience of funders who value depth, sustainability, and relevance over immediate returns.
How South African NGOs Can Build a Framework Beyond Funders’ Targets
To move from metrics-based to mission-driven impact, South African NGOs need to shift focus from targets to frameworks that honor the voices and data that already exist. Here’s how to make it happen:
Open Up Dialogue with Funders
Engage in honest conversations about why short-term metrics don’t always equate to real progress. Funders are often open to understanding that authentic change takes time and that metrics should evolve with community needs.
Pair Data with Community Stories
A balanced approach to reporting combines quantitative and qualitative data. Include case studies, community testimonials, and insights that add context to numbers. This balance shows the complexity and real impact of the work.
Bring Funders Into the Field
When funders see programs firsthand, they gain a new perspective. Community voices are powerful—they add depth to numbers and help funders see the lasting value of long-term investment.
Use Developmental Evaluation for Real-Time Learning
Developmental evaluation lets you adapt as you learn, emphasizing growth and learning over perfection. This approach is honest, transparent, and funders who understand the value of the process are often more willing to invest in sustainable results.
Request Capacity-Building Support
Reporting aligned with frameworks like SDGs and ESG takes capacity and resources. Advocating for this support helps NGOs meet high standards without detracting from the programs themselves.
Find Funders Who Understand the Real Work
Seek out partners who prioritize genuine impact. Draft proposals that emphasize the value of SDG-linked, locally adapted frameworks, drawing in funders who value long-term change over immediate, superficial results.
Be Transparent About the Full Picture
Share both successes and setbacks. Reporting what works—and what doesn’t—builds trust and underscores the reality that meaningful impact isn’t a straight line. This honesty strengthens the sector and supports sustainable partnerships.
When we let someone else’s metrics define success, we lose sight of what matters. It’s like trying to capture a song by counting beats instead of feeling the rhythm.
True impact isn’t transactional—it’s a transformation that changes lives in ways we may never fully see or measure.
For South African NGOs, the challenge is to find and follow our own beat, to listen to our communities and shape a language of impact that reflects the ground we stand on. It’s not about the numbers; it’s about the stories, the growth, and the unmeasurable shift that happens when we’re aligned with purpose.
This is how we build a future where development is more than a line item on a scorecard.
Kommentarer